Last week, I went to the Center for Cartoon Studies in White River Junction, VT for a week-long summer comics workshop. It was a very intense experience conducted by professionals that I admire and respect, and the other students were all really cool too. I had a blast, and I learned a lot about where my process usually breaks down and how I can get past that in the future. Thanks to all the staff at CCS for being totally awesome, to Gendo at the Upper Valley Zen Center for helping to open my mind to this experience, my fellow workshop students for being very good company and excellent hand models, and mostly to my wife Kim who endured a week of single motherhood, stormy sleepless nights, and the first week back at school teaching so that I could run of to New England and draw cartoons for a week.
I’ll show you the finished piece first, then I’ll go in and break down the process a bit, mainly for my own benefit so I can remember what it looked like, but also so you can see how much work can go into making comics…
After looking at it for as long as I have, I can see a million problems with it, but I think it turned out pretty well all things considered. Here’s how the process worked:
I started off Monday morning by going to the Zen Center, which I was fortunate to have discovered the night before while I was exploring White River Junction. I had this short conversation with one of the monks there, and I was struck by the image of Gendo framed by the window. After the morning comics lecture, we were asked to come up with a goal for the week. I had a short story that my best friend Todd had written, but I thought that might be too big in scope to get done in a week. So while I was waiting for the amazing Jason Lutes to come around and discuss my goal with me, I drew this sketch just so I could remember the image for later. After talking to Jason and discussing my options, I decided to expand on the sketch and draw a 4 page story about the morning’s conversation.
I had a really hard time trying to break down the conversation into a workable 4 page story, and I spent much of my studio time Monday procrastinating and idly doodling while trying to figure out how to lay this thing out. I did my portfolio review with Jason on Monday night hoping to get some tips on how to proceed, and he suggested I write out all of the dialogue, and draw one thumbnail panel for each bit of dialogue. Then I could go from there and decide how to lay it out and edit it.
This was by far the hardest part for me. I never realized it before, but I really don’t plan out what I’m doing enough. I usually do some rough layouts, but I don’t do much editing at that stage. I guess that explains why I’ve been doing pretty well at small strips that don’t require much layout, but I really struggle at longer comics. You can’t build a house without a frame!
So I muscled through it and worked late Monday night to wrangle all of these frames and dialogue into a decent 4 page layout. If you look closely at the above preliminary sketches, you can see there’s a whole scene with a cat that didn’t make it into the final layout because of space concerns.
On Tuesday I started doing rough pencils, and I went back to the Zen Center in the evening for zazen and to get some visual reference for details in the monk’s clothing and the Zen Center building layout. I got all 4 pages roughed in on Tuesday and then spent Wednesday refining them into what you see below. As you can see, I starting using very heavy pencils for the final drawings on the first two panels, but a couple of teachers wisely pointed out that I would have issues inking on top of solid black graphite, so I backed off after that. Also, Many thanks to Steve Bissette for giving me some valuable tips on how to use black placement to draw the eye.
So, after getting this done around midnight on Wednesday I went straight to bed knowing that I would have my hands full getting it inked by Friday. Fortunately Alec Longstreth gave a really inspiring talk on Thursday about time management and how to stay focused, and I used that info to make a schedule and stick to it. Because of the heavy pencils on panels one and two, I decided to just ink it using a portable light table and keep the original pencils intact. That helped a lot with the inking, and it also gave me the option of going back and finishing the whole thing in pencil if I really screwed up the inks. I worked on inking from 2:30pm on Thursday until 6:30am Friday, not sleeping at all and getting done just in time to make it to the 7am Friday zen session at the Zen Center. After sitting hunched over inking for 16 hours, sitting with correct posture for a half hour was excruciating, but when it was over I felt much better.
After Friday morning’s lecture, I scanned in the inked copies and printed out a few copies for the final critique and for trade. When I got back home, I fixed some more errors in Photoshop, and came up with the copy you read at the beginning. Voila!
Really, really great stuff!
- by illflux on August 11th, 2010 at 9:16 amThat sounds like a great experience. I’m having a hell of a time with my daily art project, and I see some huge flaws in my idea. I wish I would have planned it out better, and could have benefited from a little outside instruction that you got.
- by Andy on August 11th, 2010 at 10:23 amI just came across you through a friend. Your stuff’s pretty awesome!
- by some guy named joe on August 12th, 2010 at 12:03 amThanks, person I’ve never met before! Behold the power of networking!
- by webdisaster on August 12th, 2010 at 10:42 amYAE THATS MY TEACHER , HA HA HA HA HA , WONDERFUL
- by BOONE on August 21st, 2010 at 8:30 amI love your comic. Gendo is my husband. You totally got him, even the eyebrows. Imagine zazen spreading through comics. A perfect marriage.
- by Lianne on August 22nd, 2010 at 2:05 pmNice sequence, and I particularly enjoyed seeing the work that led up to it–the working drawings. . . which, all together, feel “a total of” letting go & letting in all at once–in gentle sequence, like breathing. “Ground, path, fruition,” Ginsberg said.
- by Peter Money on August 24th, 2010 at 10:40 pmGreat stuff Scott. I envy the opportunity to attend such an event. I look forward to seeing more.
- by Keri on August 31st, 2010 at 12:37 amGreat to meet you at the Zen center! Your comic is excellent, and portrays things so accurately, and amusingly! I am writing about my understanding of Zen and Buddhist texts over at http://trueloafing.blogspot.com . Thanks again for the hilariously real comic.
- by Colin Momeyer on September 5th, 2010 at 1:04 pmI’ve never actually known someone who has gone to a workshop of this kind. I was curious and interested in going to a writer’s workshop. I’m interested in how useful it was. I imagine there is both the pep-rally aspect (Go you! You can do it! Be all the artist you can be!) and the nitty-gritty, nuts and bolts part of it. The positive reinforcement is more important than my flippant remarks make it seem how I feel–but that’s how I am. But that’s part of the whole experience, I imagine–and the workshops must have been cool.
- by oldestgenxer on September 8th, 2010 at 11:00 pmThere’s another important part too–networking. You gotta work the room, baby!
Thanks for the excellent comic. Gendo shared it with us at the Zen Center and I encouraged him to include it in the uvzc newsletter and link to it from uvzc,org. This full exposition is great. You’re a wonderful artist.
- by james graham on October 7th, 2010 at 8:46 amScott! I love your work! This is awesome! So glad I found out about your site through the grapevine, can’t wait to share it with my son the aspiring comic writer. I especially love the idle doodle sheet where you write out the dialogue…it’s like a bit of your brain synapses on paper. Cool.
- by Julie on October 20th, 2010 at 3:20 pm